The first was the best I think. Unforgiven is my #1 Eastwood flick though. While I'm at it: Favorite Eastwood flicks...... #1 Unforgiven #2 Man with no Name Trilogy #3 Absolute Power #4Heartbreak Ridge And countless more. To be honest it is hard for me to rate my favorite Eastwood movies. I like the vast majority of his flicks minus a few.