An open letter to Obsidian Entertainment

Discussion in 'NMA News and Information' started by WorstUsernameEver, May 26, 2011.

  1. Josan

    Josan Look, Ma! Two Heads!

    384
    Oct 23, 2003
    Well, with your post as forewarning, I was able to make it past that. I gave up after the third paragraph though.
     
  2. Drifter420

    Drifter420 First time out of the vault

    34
    Feb 5, 2010
    I'm not clear as to why a bunch of you are making this reviewer out to be a BethSoft fanboy/Obsidian hater.

    First, if you read the letter, its obvious he has played and enjoyed most Obsidian games.

    Second, he's fed up with Obsidian's consistent bug problems (dating back to their Black Isle days.) A lot of people here give Obsidian a pass for this particular game, saying "oh, there's only so much you can expect when it isn't your license or engine and you've got deadlines from a publisher", but seriously, Honest Hearts received substantial development time on an engine they have been working with for three years. Would "indefinite" be enough time for Obsidian? Bad bugs are a huge part of their track record.

    Three, it seems this reviewer's breaking point was a bug caused by a patch, not from within the game, which points to sloppiness.

    Finally, there's this quote from Russ, in an article about his top 5 games of 2010:

    Lets face facts: New Vegas is bug-infested, and having put 250 hours into both games, I can tell you that my New Vegas experience was buggier than FO3 by at least a 3-1 margin. And it got worse with Honest Hearts (I'm now finding I crash on every other playthrough, within an hour most days).

    So lets actually take what this random guy on the internet says IN context, rather than chalk it up to some blind love for Bethesda.
     
  3. C2B

    C2B Look, Ma! Two Heads!

    353
    Aug 17, 2010
    Thats nice for you. Just don't assume that this is everyones experience
     
  4. TychoXI

    TychoXI Still Mildly Glowing

    246
    Oct 20, 2008
    wow. I got news for this "Russ" Pitts:

    1) Black Isle's games were quite bugged (FO1 and FO2 actually standing out in that department), so I'm not sure this guy actually "dated" BIS back in the day. Also saying Obsidian was called Black Isle is kinda an insult to, like, *half* Black Isle (who isn't at Obsidian).
    2) Fallout3 was just as bugged and glitchy as FO:NV, including unplayable DLC.
    3) Obsidian is one of the few good western RPG developers, they have they problems and I'm not gonna start citing the classic excuses for these problems their games have had, in the end it IS indeed their own fault. But yet, the games *are* good, actually in many cases they are just as buggy as the games released by other developers who somehow avoid getting frak for games which are not just buggy, but crappy as well.
     
  5. Drifter420

    Drifter420 First time out of the vault

    34
    Feb 5, 2010
    That's a great point. Just because the game doesn't breakdown for everyone means there's nothing wrong, and that people are stupid for complaining when it breaks for them. :roll:

    Also great is that I must be the exception, rather than the rule. Really? Then where is FO:NV getting this reputation?
     
  6. C2B

    C2B Look, Ma! Two Heads!

    353
    Aug 17, 2010
    Yeah, because that was my point. I was totally not reffering to your comparison with FO3. :roll:
     
  7. Drifter420

    Drifter420 First time out of the vault

    34
    Feb 5, 2010
    Right, again, I must be the exception. :roll:

    New Vegas is buggier than FO3. It is also a lot bigger, more fun, and much deeper, and I thoroughly enjoy it more. It is also buggier.
     
  8. C2B

    C2B Look, Ma! Two Heads!

    353
    Aug 17, 2010
    Then its so great that I never said you were?

    You know what? Like others here (not all) I had less problems with FO:NV than FO:3.


    Also argumenting by accusing me of something is a pretty shitty defense, dude. :|
     
  9. exmachinax

    exmachinax First time out of the vault

    13
    May 6, 2011
    Obsidian perhaps is "stuck" in the 90s, because, you know, it was in the 90's when RPGs (I mean ROLE PLAY game) were made. Simple like that. Call me nostalgic, but I see very little room to PLAY A ROLE (of my choice) in "modern" RPGs.

    Mass Effect is more a squad-shooter, shoot-and-talk game. But it looks sexy, so people jump on it because "oh it is so cool".

    Well, in fact, ME is cool. It's just don' let you choose any role to play besides the one the devs intended to. Which, IMO, is the sole point of a game said ot be a RPG at all.

    The Witcher 1 / 2 are more in tune with the RPG way, but still... it is your average fantasy setting (with more nudity and foul language, of course), geared toward combat whether you want or not. But it is cool, too, so all is good, I suppose.

    But a lot of people just don't forgive a company that simply don't realease a game as cool as it can be. Obsidian prefers to create well thought, fully realized worlds, instead of resorting to the "playground" tactic. As I said, it seems to be unforgivable.
     
  10. C2B

    C2B Look, Ma! Two Heads!

    353
    Aug 17, 2010
    I'm pretty sure Lexx made a joke^^
     
  11. Tel Prydain

    Tel Prydain First time out of the vault

    35
    Apr 23, 2007
    " I thought that maybe if you could spend some time in your old neighborhood you would realize how much things have changed - and how much you haven't. I had hoped that seeing what your friends had done with the place might inspire you to be better."

    Wait - So he’s saying the game with the choice-free world where stores are still packed with food that no-one has pilfered over the last TWO HUNDRED YEARS has anything to teach the game with hardcore mode, non-linear story, quests with multiple solutions, characters with actual character and a world that actually acts like it’s 200 years after the bomb?
    I can not BOOOO him hard enough.
     
  12. Elven6

    Elven6 It Wandered In From the Wastes

    165
    Oct 23, 2010
    Didn't the original game end with the characters waving to the camera on the "beach planet"?

    How foolish of them to not end their game, which opens with a massacre on a colony and ship set in a war torn galaxy on a high note!

    Haven't played any of the Neverwinter Nights 2 titles so I can't comment on them but I am playing through Alpha Protocol. While I haven't encountered any bugs, the animations are pretty ridiculous and I think it's insane that they sat on that build of the game for six months without doing anything to it (I defend Obsidian's quality quite a bit but once AP released in its state I didn't have much ground to stand on anymore).
     
  13. HyperionOmega

    HyperionOmega First time out of the vault

    26
    Nov 3, 2010
    Well seems once again I agree with the minority here. Much as Drifter420 I had oodles more game breaking bugs with NV than I did with Fallout 3.
    Also I had more enjoyment out of Fallout 3 and eagerly awaited NV to see if the "old boys" who made the first Fallouts could outshine Bethesda in their long lost IP.
    Much to my sadness they did not. At first it seemed like it was only me that felt disappointment with the game and the DLC (I haven't played HH so I won't comment on that) but now this letter shows that a lot of people have turned against NV.
     
  14. Ilosar

    Ilosar Vault Fossil

    Apr 20, 2010
    It's less against NV and more against Obsidian's admittedly shitty track record on the technical side (as the quote proves, he like NV more than Fallout 3). I disagree with the guy, but I can definitely see where he comes from, no Obsidian game didn't include loads of bugs (some didn't even have a proper ending, looking at you KOTOR2, even if they are not the only ones, looking at you now TW2). Of course, most of KOTOR 2 and New Vegas's bugginess was due to the engine, not that much they can do, but Alpha Protocol was very much their fault.
     
  15. Lexx

    Lexx Testament to the ghoul lifespan
    Moderator Modder

    Apr 24, 2005
    While I don't denie the truth in this, I don't think it matters much for FNV, as it's DLCs are pretty much separate from the main game, except some minor connections. So it's not like a FNV DLC is fiddleing around a lot with content from the main game.
    I'll guess the ED-E bug is a pure and totally unexpected bug. I mean, seriously, who would have thought that something like this can happen at all? Even as a tester, I wouldn't have thought about testing such thing.

    Yes, but sarcasm doesn't work well with text. :>
     
  16. sampson70

    sampson70 Still Mildly Glowing

    219
    Dec 1, 2009
    I totally agree that FNV was bugger than FO3.Maybe its was different for most of you PC gamers,but the 360 version was truly worst.
     
  17. Killzig

    Killzig It Wandered In From the Wastes

    174
    Apr 12, 2003
    It was the first time that engine had been called upon to handle real RPG scripting, the bugs were expected.
     
    • [Rad] [Rad] x 1
  18. shihonage

    shihonage Made in USSR

    May 8, 2007
    I addressed this in the rest of my post. Isolated corridor DLCs are not a graceful way to expand a C&C-rich game like Fallout. It is a way to expand isolated corridor games like Mass Effect, where freedom has always been entirely illusionary.
     
  19. Khan FurSainty

    Khan FurSainty Look, Ma! Two Heads!

    332
    Apr 23, 2009
    Or, a better idea, drop the DLCs as a whole and get back to expansion. I know it's not going to happen because of financial problems, but if you get to a point where you need to sell parts of a game just to stay in business, you might as well just put on your coat and developer hat and look for another job.
     
  20. C2B

    C2B Look, Ma! Two Heads!

    353
    Aug 17, 2010
    Regarding AP. The whole development was a mess for internal and external reasons. The 6 month wait time at the end was on SEGAs end though. Also the PC patch was in QA Hell on SEGA before it was released.... For the US Version... It needed a steam release for SEGA to adjust the executable for other countries.

    You can read a lot of it in the Something Awful Alpha Protocol Thread where a Ex-Obsidian employee also posts (Patrick K. Mills)

    http://forums.somethingawful.com/showthread.php?threadid=3308998&pagenumber=253#post392028548

    http://forums.somethingawful.com/showthread.php?threadid=3308998&userid=19836

    (Patrick Mills is Comte)

    Still its actually my favorite Obsidian game and by faaaar the least buggy. As for unbalanced gameplay. I would have trouble naming it worse than NWN2, But that had more options so it wasn't that obvious.