No but the one eom posted did. The ones I posted mentioned REE primarily. You said only Helium-3 and Water existed on the Moon and nothing else. You stated that nothing else of value could be found there. I just posted those to show you that many things could be there, but you simply won't accept it which is fine. You didn't respond to his post, so you may have missed it. Edit: You seem to be stuck on the Gold thing. I did mention REE a few times. You may have missed that while I was editing. REE will be pretty valuable in the future I think. You may be trying to argue the "gold and platinum" point, when I am more trying to argue the "elements of value" point.